History Atlas

How The Past Is Known

History Atlas

Disputed Statements

Claims this atlas currently marks as unsettled or as tested and found false. A debated fact is one scholars hold competing positions on; a debunked one has been checked against the record and found not to hold. Both are kept in view rather than quietly smoothed over, with the reasoning that put each one where it stands.

152 statements marked Debated.

Ancient Egypt, Start Year-3100

Ancient Egypt, Civilizations

Standing

Concerns Start Year

Currently States -3100

The unification of Upper and Lower Egypt under Narmer, or Menes in later tradition, is conventionally dated around 3100 BCE, but estimates in the scholarly literature range from roughly 3150 to 3000 BCE depending on the chronology used.

Source The Cambridge Ancient History

Ancient Greece, Start Year-800

Ancient Greece, Civilizations

Standing

Concerns Start Year

Currently States -800

As with the era it opens, historians vary between 800, 776 and 750 BCE for the start of the Archaic Greek world; none of these is a single dated event.

Source Encyclopaedia Britannica

Atahualpa, Birth Year1502

Atahualpa, Historical Figures

Standing

Concerns Birth Year

Currently States 1502

Circa 1502 per Atahualpa's own deathbed declaration, a claim historians dispute; recorded here as the infobox's own approximate value, not as settled fact.

Source Wikipedia: Atahualpa

Attila the Hun, Birth Year406

Attila the Hun, Historical Figures

Standing

Concerns Birth Year

Currently States 406

No contemporary source records Attila's birth; circa 406 is the modern scholarly estimate from his approximate age at death.

Source The Cambridge Medieval History

Bi Sheng, Birth Year972

Bi Sheng, Historical Figures

Standing

Concerns Birth Year

Currently States 972

Only his death in 1051 is precisely attested in the primary source (Shen Kuo Dream Pool Essays); 972 is the approximate birth year usually given from the traditional biographical range of 972-1051.

Source Wikipedia: Bi Sheng

Carthage, Start Year-814

Carthage, Civilizations

Standing

Concerns Start Year

Currently States -814

Ancient historiography (Timaeus and later writers) dated Carthage's founding to 814 BCE and credited Dido of Tyre, whose own historicity is questioned, but the earliest archaeological occupation excavated so far dates only to the eighth century BCE. The atlas records the traditional 814 BCE date while flagging the gap between legend and archaeology as unresolved; see the linked open question.

Source Wikipedia: Carthage

Chandragupta II, Death PlacePataliputra, possibly Ujjain (Gupta Empire)

Chandragupta II, Historical Figures

Standing

Concerns Death Place

Currently States Pataliputra, possibly Ujjain (Gupta Empire)

Sources place his death at the Gupta capital Pataliputra, though some suggest Ujjain instead.

Source Wikipedia: Chandragupta II

Charlemagne, Birth Year748

Charlemagne, Historical Figures

Standing

Concerns Birth Year

Currently States 748

Charlemagne's exact birth year is not certainly known. Most historians now favor 748 CE over the once standard 742, based on later research into the sources.

Source The Cambridge Medieval History

Charlemagne, BirthplaceHerstal, in present-day Belgium (the location most historians favor)

Charlemagne, Historical Figures

Standing

Concerns Birthplace

Currently States Herstal, in present-day Belgium (the location most historians favor)

Charlemagne's birthplace is not securely attested. Besides Herstal, historians have proposed Liege, Aachen, Ingelheim, Duren and Prum, reflecting how little eighth-century record survives; Aachen, sometimes assumed because of his later palace there, is not itself well supported as his birthplace.

Source Wikipedia

Classical Antiquity, Start Year-800

Classical Antiquity, Eras

Standing

Concerns Start Year

Currently States -800

Some historians prefer 776 BCE, the traditional date of the first Olympic Games, or 750 BCE, roughly when the Greek alphabet and the earliest poleis appear. 800 BCE is a convenient round marker for the start of the Archaic period rather than a precisely dated event.

Source Encyclopaedia Britannica

Classical Antiquity, End Year476

Classical Antiquity, Eras

Standing

Concerns End Year

Currently States 476

476 CE, the traditional date of the deposition of the last Western Roman emperor, Romulus Augustulus, is a convenient political marker, but historians increasingly treat the end of antiquity as a gradual transformation rather than a single collapse, and some prefer 330 CE, the founding of Constantinople, or 500 CE as alternative boundaries.

Source The Cambridge Ancient History

Cleopatra VII, Birth Year-69

Cleopatra VII, Historical Figures

Standing

Concerns Birth Year

Currently States -69

Conventionally dated to 70 or 69 BCE; ancient sources give no precise record of her birth.

Source The Cambridge Ancient History

Cyrus the Great, Birth Year-600

Cyrus the Great, Historical Figures

Standing

Concerns Birth Year

Currently States -600

Sources place his birth around 600 BC; the exact year is not precisely attested and is conventionally given as circa.

Edgar J. Kaufmann Sr., DescriptionUneasy about Wright's limited experience with reinforced concrete, Kaufmann had the cantilever design reviewed by outside consulting engineers without first telling Wright. When their report recommended substantially more steel than Wright had specified, Wright took the review as a breach of trust, demanded his drawings back, and threatened to withdraw from the project entirely; Kaufmann backed down and the report was set aside. The reinforcement was increased regardless, before the concrete was poured, either by the contractor acting quietly or by Kaufmann's own engineers redrawing Wright's rebar plans; accounts differ on which. Wright, on learning of it, wrote to Kaufmann that he had put more into the house than any client had a right to expect, and that without Kaufmann's confidence the whole project could go to hell. The house has stood since 1937, though its longest cantilever had sagged as much as seven inches by the 1990s, arrested by a 2002 post-tensioning repair.

Edgar J. Kaufmann Sr., Historical Figures

Standing

Concerns Description

Currently States Uneasy about Wright's limited experience with reinforced concrete, Kaufmann had the cantilever design reviewed by outside consulting engineers without first telling Wright. When their report recommended substantially more steel than Wright had specified, Wright took the review as a breach of trust, demanded his drawings back, and threatened to withdraw from the project entirely; Kaufmann backed down and the report was set aside. The reinforcement was increased regardless, before the concrete was poured, either by the contractor acting quietly or by Kaufmann's own engineers redrawing Wright's rebar plans; accounts differ on which. Wright, on learning of it, wrote to Kaufmann that he had put more into the house than any client had a right to expect, and that without Kaufmann's confidence the whole project could go to hell. The house has stood since 1937, though its longest cantilever had sagged as much as seven inches by the 1990s, arrested by a 2002 post-tensioning repair.

Sources agree the cantilever reinforcement Wright's staff engineer Mendel Glickman specified was substantially increased before the concrete was poured, and that Wright was furious about it, but disagree on exactly who ordered the increase and how directly his objection was overridden.

Source Misfits' Architecture

Edith Farnsworth, DescriptionArchitectural historian Nora Wendl has argued that the enduring popular story casting Farnsworth as a scorned, jilted woman whose lawsuit was driven by romantic rejection is a misogynistic distortion with little documentary support; Farnsworth's own memoirs are notably discreet on the subject, and pages are missing. Wendl's reading of the trial transcript and correspondence instead finds two people with fundamentally incompatible visions for the house, and a dispute rooted in Farnsworth's refusal to keep paying escalating costs, not in spurned affection. She argues the romantic framing reduced a physician and translator to the tired trope of the jealous ex-lover, obscuring what the dispute was actually about.

Edith Farnsworth, Historical Figures

Standing

Concerns Description

Currently States Architectural historian Nora Wendl has argued that the enduring popular story casting Farnsworth as a scorned, jilted woman whose lawsuit was driven by romantic rejection is a misogynistic distortion with little documentary support; Farnsworth's own memoirs are notably discreet on the subject, and pages are missing. Wendl's reading of the trial transcript and correspondence instead finds two people with fundamentally incompatible visions for the house, and a dispute rooted in Farnsworth's refusal to keep paying escalating costs, not in spurned affection. She argues the romantic framing reduced a physician and translator to the tired trope of the jealous ex-lover, obscuring what the dispute was actually about.

Popular accounts long framed Farnsworth as a spurned romantic interest who sued out of wounded feeling; architectural historian Nora Wendl's archival research, drawing on the trial record and Farnsworth's own correspondence, argues this reading is an unsupported later invention.

Source Chicago Sun-Times

Edith Farnsworth, Death Date1977-12-05

Edith Farnsworth, Historical Figures

Standing

Concerns Death Date

Currently States 1977-12-05

Sources disagree between December 4 and December 5, 1977.

Source Wikipedia

Edward II of England, DescriptionEdward II was king of England from 1307 to 1327, the fourth son but only surviving son of Edward I. He inherited a treasury deficit of some 200,000 pounds and an unfinished Scottish war, and none of his father's strengths for handling either. He rejected the company of his own class for that of Piers Gaveston, a Gascon knight's son with whom he probably had a homosexual relationship; Gaveston's recall from exile and his elevation to the earldom of Cornwall provoked baronial fury that culminated in the Ordinances of 1311, a program of reform that curtailed royal patronage and exiled Gaveston again, and in Gaveston's capture and execution by the barons in 1312. Edward's catastrophic defeat by Robert the Bruce at Bannockburn in 1314 further weakened his authority, and the middle years of the reign were dominated by his cousin Thomas of Lancaster until Edward crushed him in the brief civil war of 1321 to 1322 and had him executed. New royal favourites, the two Hugh Despensers, father and son, then dominated the final years of the reign, presiding over real administrative reforms alongside blatant corruption. In 1326 Edward's estranged queen, Isabella of France, invaded with her ally Roger Mortimer; the Despensers were captured and executed, and Edward himself was captured, imprisoned, and in January 1327 deposed by Parliament in favour of his fourteen-year-old son, Edward III, the first time an anointed king of England had been removed from power by his own subjects since Aethelred II in 1013. He was almost certainly killed at Berkeley Castle later that year, though the manner and even the fact of his death were disputed within a decade (see the recorded dissent).

Edward II of England, Historical Figures

Standing

Concerns Description

Currently States Edward II was king of England from 1307 to 1327, the fourth son but only surviving son of Edward I. He inherited a treasury deficit of some 200,000 pounds and an unfinished Scottish war, and none of his father's strengths for handling either. He rejected the company of his own class for that of Piers Gaveston, a Gascon knight's son with whom he probably had a homosexual relationship; Gaveston's recall from exile and his elevation to the earldom of Cornwall provoked baronial fury that culminated in the Ordinances of 1311, a program of reform that curtailed royal patronage and exiled Gaveston again, and in Gaveston's capture and execution by the barons in 1312. Edward's catastrophic defeat by Robert the Bruce at Bannockburn in 1314 further weakened his authority, and the middle years of the reign were dominated by his cousin Thomas of Lancaster until Edward crushed him in the brief civil war of 1321 to 1322 and had him executed. New royal favourites, the two Hugh Despensers, father and son, then dominated the final years of the reign, presiding over real administrative reforms alongside blatant corruption. In 1326 Edward's estranged queen, Isabella of France, invaded with her ally Roger Mortimer; the Despensers were captured and executed, and Edward himself was captured, imprisoned, and in January 1327 deposed by Parliament in favour of his fourteen-year-old son, Edward III, the first time an anointed king of England had been removed from power by his own subjects since Aethelred II in 1013. He was almost certainly killed at Berkeley Castle later that year, though the manner and even the fact of his death were disputed within a decade (see the recorded dissent).

Source United Kingdom: Edward I and Edward II (Britannica)

Edward III of England, DescriptionEdward III was king of England from 1327 to 1377, crowned at fourteen after his father Edward II's forced deposition. For four years Isabella of France and Roger Mortimer governed in his name; in October 1330 Edward had Mortimer seized at Nottingham Castle and executed, and began to rule in earnest. He revived the Scottish war his father had lost, then in 1337, following the French crown's confiscation of Gascony and his own revived claim to the French throne itself, a claim resting on his mother Isabella's blood as sister of the last direct Capetian king, he opened the conflict historians call the Hundred Years' War. His victories at Sluys (1340), Crecy (1346) and the capture of Calais (1347) were followed by his son Edward, the Black Prince's, victory and capture of the French king John II at Poitiers (1356), and the 1360 Treaty of Calais briefly secured full sovereignty over an enlarged Aquitaine in exchange for renouncing the French crown. During the 1340s Edward also rebuilt Windsor Castle and founded the Order of the Garter, and Parliament grew in strength through his repeated need to secure grants for the war, passing the Statutes of Provisors (1351) and Praemunire (1353) against papal encroachment on English benefices and the Statute of Labourers (1351) after the Black Death first struck England in 1348 and 1349. The war reopened in 1369 and went badly; after Queen Philippa's death that year Edward fell under the influence of his mistress Alice Perrers, and the Good Parliament of 1376 impeached several of his ministers and Perrers herself for corruption before the Black Prince's death that June and Edward's own failing health let John of Gaunt reverse its reforms. Older, chronicle-derived tradition remembers Edward's fifty-year reign as a golden age of chivalry and military triumph; historians who weigh the reign whole read its final two decades as a genuine decline rather than a coda to unbroken success (see the recorded dissent).

Edward III of England, Historical Figures

Standing

Concerns Description

Currently States Edward III was king of England from 1327 to 1377, crowned at fourteen after his father Edward II's forced deposition. For four years Isabella of France and Roger Mortimer governed in his name; in October 1330 Edward had Mortimer seized at Nottingham Castle and executed, and began to rule in earnest. He revived the Scottish war his father had lost, then in 1337, following the French crown's confiscation of Gascony and his own revived claim to the French throne itself, a claim resting on his mother Isabella's blood as sister of the last direct Capetian king, he opened the conflict historians call the Hundred Years' War. His victories at Sluys (1340), Crecy (1346) and the capture of Calais (1347) were followed by his son Edward, the Black Prince's, victory and capture of the French king John II at Poitiers (1356), and the 1360 Treaty of Calais briefly secured full sovereignty over an enlarged Aquitaine in exchange for renouncing the French crown. During the 1340s Edward also rebuilt Windsor Castle and founded the Order of the Garter, and Parliament grew in strength through his repeated need to secure grants for the war, passing the Statutes of Provisors (1351) and Praemunire (1353) against papal encroachment on English benefices and the Statute of Labourers (1351) after the Black Death first struck England in 1348 and 1349. The war reopened in 1369 and went badly; after Queen Philippa's death that year Edward fell under the influence of his mistress Alice Perrers, and the Good Parliament of 1376 impeached several of his ministers and Perrers herself for corruption before the Black Prince's death that June and Edward's own failing health let John of Gaunt reverse its reforms. Older, chronicle-derived tradition remembers Edward's fifty-year reign as a golden age of chivalry and military triumph; historians who weigh the reign whole read its final two decades as a genuine decline rather than a coda to unbroken success (see the recorded dissent).

Source Edward III (Britannica)

French East India Company, Dissolved1794

French East India Company, Organizations

Standing

Concerns Dissolved

Currently States 1794

The company passed through repeated insolvency and reorganization (bankrupt 1685, restructured, bankrupt again 1706, absorbed into John Law's Company in 1719 and continued as the Compagnie des Indes) before its final liquidation in 1794; sources differ on which point marks its true end.

French Wars of Religion, Death Toll, Low Estimate2000000.000000

French Wars of Religion, Events

Standing

Concerns Death Toll, Low Estimate

Currently States 2000000.000000

The lower end of the total war-dead estimate, from violence, famine and disease over the eight wars, roughly a tenth of France's pre-war population. The figure has been specifically challenged as difficult to verify against the surviving parish and military records, so it is recorded here as the widely cited estimate rather than a settled count.

Source The French Wars of Religion, 1559-1598, R. J. Knecht