History Atlas

How The Past Is Known

History Atlas

Disputed Statements

Claims this atlas currently marks as unsettled or as tested and found false. A debated fact is one scholars hold competing positions on; a debunked one has been checked against the record and found not to hold. Both are kept in view rather than quietly smoothed over, with the reasoning that put each one where it stands.

152 statements marked Debated.

Thirty Years War, Death Toll, Low Estimate4500000.000000

Thirty Years War, Events

Standing

Concerns Death Toll, Low Estimate

Currently States 4500000.000000

The lower end of the range general histories cite for total deaths across the war zone from combat, disease and famine combined; a count of direct military dead alone would be substantially smaller.

Source Europe's Tragedy: A History of the Thirty Years War, Peter H. Wilson

Thirty Years War, Death Toll, High Estimate8000000.000000

Thirty Years War, Events

Standing

Concerns Death Toll, High Estimate

Currently States 8000000.000000

The higher end of the same range, consistent with estimates that close to a quarter of the population of the German lands died as a result of the war, overwhelmingly to disease and starvation following the collapse of civil order rather than to battle itself.

Source Europe's Tragedy: A History of the Thirty Years War, Peter H. Wilson

Tulip Mania, DescriptionA period in the Dutch Republic, peaking in the winter of 1636 to 1637, during which contract prices for tulip bulbs, especially rare virus-streaked broken varieties, rose to extraordinary levels before collapsing in February 1637. Traditionally presented as history's first recorded speculative bubble and a byword for irrational market mania, it sits inside the Dutch Golden Age, the same decades of commercial wealth, colonial trade and civic pride that produced the Dutch Republic's rise as a maritime and financial power. The scale of the traditional account is itself a live dispute among economic historians: Peter Garber and others working from surviving notarial and contract records argue the episode was a much smaller, largely futures-market phenomenon among specialist growers and traders rather than an economy-wide mania, a revisionist reading that has not displaced the traditional account in general reference works.

Tulip Mania, Events

Standing

Concerns Description

Currently States A period in the Dutch Republic, peaking in the winter of 1636 to 1637, during which contract prices for tulip bulbs, especially rare virus-streaked broken varieties, rose to extraordinary levels before collapsing in February 1637. Traditionally presented as history's first recorded speculative bubble and a byword for irrational market mania, it sits inside the Dutch Golden Age, the same decades of commercial wealth, colonial trade and civic pride that produced the Dutch Republic's rise as a maritime and financial power. The scale of the traditional account is itself a live dispute among economic historians: Peter Garber and others working from surviving notarial and contract records argue the episode was a much smaller, largely futures-market phenomenon among specialist growers and traders rather than an economy-wide mania, a revisionist reading that has not displaced the traditional account in general reference works.

The traditional irrational-mania account is the one repeated in most general reference works; the Garber revisionist reading, based on surviving notarial and contract records, holds the episode was far narrower in scope. Both readings are live in the secondary literature.

Source Tulip Mania (Encyclopaedia Britannica)

War of the Third Coalition, Death Toll, Low Estimate62050.000000

War of the Third Coalition, Events

Standing

Concerns Death Toll, Low Estimate

Currently States 62050.000000

French and allied forces' own killed, wounded or captured across the 1805-1806 campaign, per the aggregate casualty figures on record for this conflict. This is the SMALLER of two reasonable readings of the war's toll; see death-toll-max for the combined-both-sides figure.

Source Wikipedia: War of the Third Coalition

War of the Third Coalition, Death Toll, High Estimate222050.000000

War of the Third Coalition, Events

Standing

Concerns Death Toll, High Estimate

Currently States 222050.000000

Combined killed, wounded or captured across BOTH sides (allied forces 160,000 plus French and allied forces 62,050), the larger of two reasonable readings; see death-toll-min for the French/allied-only figure. The two numbers answer different questions (one side vs. both) rather than representing a genuine high/low disagreement about the same quantity.

Source Wikipedia: War of the Third Coalition

Wars of Alexander the Great, Death Toll, Low Estimate1000000.000000

Wars of Alexander the Great, Events

Standing

Concerns Death Toll, Low Estimate

Currently States 1000000.000000

Aggregate order-of-magnitude estimate across all of Alexander's campaigns (336-323 BCE, Greece through Persia to India). Ancient battle-casualty figures (Arrian, Diodorus, Plutarch) are notoriously unreliable, often propagandistic in either direction, so this figure is treated as illustrative of scale rather than a precise count.

Source Wikipedia: Wars of Alexander the Great

Weimar Republic, DescriptionThe German republic that succeeded the German Empire, proclaimed 9 November 1918 and constituted under a National Assembly that met at Weimar and adopted its constitution 11 August 1919. It combined a popularly elected president holding sweeping Article 48 emergency powers with a Reichstag elected by pure proportional representation, a combination the US Holocaust Memorial Museum describes as having drastically weakened a system already under extreme tension. The Republic survived the 1920 Kapp Putsch, the 1923 hyperinflation and the 1923 Beer Hall Putsch, but its parliamentary government effectively ended when President Hindenburg appointed Adolf Hitler chancellor on 30 January 1933, followed by the Enabling Act of 23 March 1933.

Weimar Republic, Polities

Standing

Concerns Description

Currently States The German republic that succeeded the German Empire, proclaimed 9 November 1918 and constituted under a National Assembly that met at Weimar and adopted its constitution 11 August 1919. It combined a popularly elected president holding sweeping Article 48 emergency powers with a Reichstag elected by pure proportional representation, a combination the US Holocaust Memorial Museum describes as having drastically weakened a system already under extreme tension. The Republic survived the 1920 Kapp Putsch, the 1923 hyperinflation and the 1923 Beer Hall Putsch, but its parliamentary government effectively ended when President Hindenburg appointed Adolf Hitler chancellor on 30 January 1933, followed by the Enabling Act of 23 March 1933.

Source Article 48 (USHMM Holocaust Encyclopedia)

William Marshal, 1st Earl of Pembroke, Birth Year1146

William Marshal, 1st Earl of Pembroke, Historical Figures

Standing

Concerns Birth Year

Currently States 1146

Wikipedia gives 1146 or 1147 as the two candidate birth years; 1146 is recorded here.

Source Wikipedia: William Marshal, 1st Earl of Pembroke

William Wallace, Birth Year1270

William Wallace, Historical Figures

Standing

Concerns Birth Year

Currently States 1270

Wikipedia gives the birth year as c. 1270 according to tradition; no precise attested date exists.

Source Wikipedia: William Wallace

World War I, DescriptionWorld War I was a global conflict fought from 1914 to 1918, chiefly among the great powers of Europe and eventually drawing in the United States, the Ottoman Empire and much of the colonized world, that killed an estimated fifteen to twenty two million people and destroyed the pre-war European order of dynastic empires. Its trigger was the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand, heir to the Austro-Hungarian throne, by the Bosnian Serb Gavrilo Princip in Sarajevo on 28 June 1914, but the crisis that followed, conventionally called the July Crisis, turned a localized Balkan dispute into a general war through a chain of alliance commitments and mobilization decisions. Germany gave Austria-Hungary an unconditional guarantee of support, the so called blank cheque, on 5 July; Austria-Hungary issued Serbia a deliberately unacceptable ultimatum on 23 July and declared war on 28 July; Russia's general mobilization in Serbia's defense on 30 July drew a German ultimatum demanding it stand down, and when that expired unanswered, Germany declared war on Russia on 1 August and on France on 3 August. Germany's invasion of Belgium on 4 August, in violation of an 1839 treaty Britain had guaranteed, brought Britain and its empire into the war the same day, making it a global conflict within a single week. On the Western Front the war settled by late 1914 into trench warfare across a line running from the Belgian coast to Switzerland, where industrialized firepower, machine guns, heavy artillery and eventually poison gas and tanks produced enormous casualties for minimal territorial change, at battles such as Verdun and the Somme in 1916. The Eastern Front, the Gallipoli campaign against the Ottoman Empire, war in the Middle East and Africa, and an unrestricted submarine campaign that helped bring the United States into the war in April 1917 made this the first war fought on a genuinely worldwide scale. Russia's own 1917 revolutions took it out of the war, while the United States' entry and Germany's failed spring 1918 offensive turned the balance decisively against the Central Powers, who sued for peace; an armistice took effect on 11 November 1918, followed by the Treaty of Versailles in 1919. Historians remain divided over how to apportion responsibility for the war's outbreak among the great powers, and over whether the July Crisis reflects deliberate aggression, systemic failure, or both.

World War I, Events

Standing

Concerns Description

Currently States World War I was a global conflict fought from 1914 to 1918, chiefly among the great powers of Europe and eventually drawing in the United States, the Ottoman Empire and much of the colonized world, that killed an estimated fifteen to twenty two million people and destroyed the pre-war European order of dynastic empires. Its trigger was the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand, heir to the Austro-Hungarian throne, by the Bosnian Serb Gavrilo Princip in Sarajevo on 28 June 1914, but the crisis that followed, conventionally called the July Crisis, turned a localized Balkan dispute into a general war through a chain of alliance commitments and mobilization decisions. Germany gave Austria-Hungary an unconditional guarantee of support, the so called blank cheque, on 5 July; Austria-Hungary issued Serbia a deliberately unacceptable ultimatum on 23 July and declared war on 28 July; Russia's general mobilization in Serbia's defense on 30 July drew a German ultimatum demanding it stand down, and when that expired unanswered, Germany declared war on Russia on 1 August and on France on 3 August. Germany's invasion of Belgium on 4 August, in violation of an 1839 treaty Britain had guaranteed, brought Britain and its empire into the war the same day, making it a global conflict within a single week. On the Western Front the war settled by late 1914 into trench warfare across a line running from the Belgian coast to Switzerland, where industrialized firepower, machine guns, heavy artillery and eventually poison gas and tanks produced enormous casualties for minimal territorial change, at battles such as Verdun and the Somme in 1916. The Eastern Front, the Gallipoli campaign against the Ottoman Empire, war in the Middle East and Africa, and an unrestricted submarine campaign that helped bring the United States into the war in April 1917 made this the first war fought on a genuinely worldwide scale. Russia's own 1917 revolutions took it out of the war, while the United States' entry and Germany's failed spring 1918 offensive turned the balance decisively against the Central Powers, who sued for peace; an armistice took effect on 11 November 1918, followed by the Treaty of Versailles in 1919. Historians remain divided over how to apportion responsibility for the war's outbreak among the great powers, and over whether the July Crisis reflects deliberate aggression, systemic failure, or both.

Source Outbreak of the First World War (Imperial War Museums)

World War I, Death Toll, Low Estimate15000000.000000

World War I, Events

Standing

Concerns Death Toll, Low Estimate

Currently States 15000000.000000

The lower end of commonly cited total death estimates, military and civilian combined. Estimates of military deaths alone generally run from nine to eleven million; adding an estimated six to thirteen million civilian deaths from military action, starvation, disease, exposure and massacre produces the wider fifteen to twenty two million range this entity carries. Some totals additionally fold in the 1918 to 1919 influenza pandemic, which overlapped with and was worsened by wartime conditions but is conventionally treated as a separate event.

Source World War I: Killed, Wounded, and Missing (Britannica)

World War I, Death Toll, High Estimate22000000.000000

World War I, Events

Standing

Concerns Death Toll, High Estimate

Currently States 22000000.000000

The higher end of commonly cited total death estimates; Britannica's own figures of roughly 8.5 million military deaths and roughly 13 million civilian deaths sum to close to this range.

Source World War I: Killed, Wounded, and Missing (Britannica)